Long Island, with its rich history stretching back to Native American tribes and European settlers in the 1600s, is home to some of the most haunted places in New York. From abandoned psychiatric hospitals to eerie mansions and haunted roads, the island is filled with spooky locations and ghost stories that have stood the test of time. If you're brave enough to explore, here are 13 of the creepiest haunted places on Long Island.
1. Mount Misery & Sweet Hollow Road - Huntington
One of the most notorious haunted places on Long Island is Mount Misery. This area is filled with creepy tales of ghostly apparitions, including a faceless police officer and the infamous "Lady in White," who is said to haunt Sweet Hollow Road. Legends speak of a hospital that burned down twice, trapping its patients inside, and the spirits are said to linger, haunting the grounds to this day. Visitors report eerie sightings and paranormal activity, making it a must-visit for those interested in Long Island’s most haunted places.
2. Kings Park Psychiatric Center - Kings Park
If you're looking for real haunted places to visit on Long Island, Kings Park Psychiatric Center is at the top of the list. Once home to over 9,000 patients, this abandoned psychiatric hospital is known for its dark past, including controversial treatments like lobotomies and electric shock therapy. The decaying buildings and underground tunnels have made this location a hotspot for ghost hunters. Many visitors have reported hearing the screams of patients and seeing shadowy figures, solidifying its reputation as one of the most haunted places in Long Island.
3. Lake Ronkonkoma
Known for both its beauty and its chilling legends, Lake Ronkonkoma is Long Island’s largest freshwater lake and a sacred site for Native American tribes. However, it's best known for the ghost story of an Indian princess who is said to haunt the lake, claiming the lives of young men as revenge for her lover’s murder. Many believe that the lake is cursed, with at least one male drowning every year. This eerie legend has made Lake Ronkonkoma a go-to destination for those seeking paranormal activity in Long Island.
4. Raynham Hall - Oyster Bay
Raynham Hall, located in Oyster Bay, is one of Long Island's best-known haunted houses. This 18th-century home played a significant role during the Revolutionary War and is said to be haunted by the spirits of Sally Townsend and British officer John Graves Simcoe. The ghost of Major John Andre, who was hanged for treason, is also rumored to linger here. Visitors claim to have seen apparitions and felt unexplained cold spots, making Raynham Hall one of the most haunted historical sites on Long Island.
5. Katie’s Bar - Smithtown
For a spooky night out, stop by Katie’s Bar in Smithtown. This local bar has been the setting for numerous ghost sightings, particularly of a Prohibition-era bartender named Charlie Klein. Patrons and staff have reported objects moving on their own, doors swinging open, and even ghostly figures appearing. This makes Katie’s one of the most haunted locations in Long Island, perfect for those seeking an eerie experience.
6. Morgan Hall - Glen Cove
Once the grand estate of financier J.P. Morgan, Morgan Hall is now a haunted mansion shrouded in mystery. The ghost of Morgan’s daughter Alice, who died from typhoid fever, is said to roam the halls, with sightings of her dressed in a long black gown. The mansion's dark history and eerie atmosphere make it a popular spot for ghost hunters seeking out haunted mansions on Long Island.
7. Wickham Farmhouse - Cutchogue
The Wickham Farmhouse in Cutchogue is one of the oldest English-style homes on Long Island, and it’s also one of the creepiest. In 1854, the farmhouse was the site of a brutal axe murder that claimed the lives of James and Frances Wickham. Visitors have reported seeing ghostly apparitions and hearing strange noises, earning its place as one of the most haunted houses on Long Island.
8. The Normandie Inn - Bohemia
This abandoned building once served as a speakeasy during Prohibition and is now rumored to be haunted by the spirit of a woman named Maria, who was strangled to death in one of the upstairs rooms. People claim to hear knocking on doors and footsteps in the hallways, even though the inn has been closed for years. If you’re searching for a truly unsettling haunted location, The Normandie Inn is a must-visit.
9. Reid Ice Cream Grounds - Blue Point
In 1966, the body of a young woman was discovered at the Reid Ice Cream Grounds, bound and murdered. The ghost of this woman is said to linger, haunting the grounds where she met her untimely end. Paranormal investigators have reported strange occurrences, making this site one of the more eerie and haunted places on Long Island.
10. Country House Restaurant - Stony Brook
The Country House Restaurant in Stony Brook is not only known for its food but also its ghosts. Built in 1710, the restaurant is haunted by the spirit of Annette Williamson, who was murdered during the Revolutionary War. The current owner has reported multiple ghostly encounters, including objects moving and light bulbs mysteriously blowing out. This haunted restaurant is a must-visit for history buffs and ghost enthusiasts alike.
11. Fire Island Lighthouse - Fire Island
Standing tall for more than 150 years, the Fire Island Lighthouse is believed to be a beacon not just for ships but for spirits as well. The ghost of a lighthouse keeper who committed suicide is said to wander the grounds, and many visitors report strange lights and sounds. This is a popular destination for those looking for haunted locations on Long Island.
12. Winfield Hall - Glen Cove
Winfield Hall, the former estate of retail tycoon F.W. Woolworth, is one of the creepiest haunted mansions on Long Island. The ghost of Woolworth’s daughter, Edna, is said to haunt the estate, with reports of locked rooms and eerie furniture movements. Its dark history and occult rumors make it a top spot for ghost hunters seeking haunted Long Island mansions.
13. Southampton Campus Windmill - Stony Brook University
Built in 1712, the windmill at Stony Brook University’s Southampton campus is one of the oldest structures on Long Island, and it’s haunted by the ghost of a little girl who died falling down its stairs. Students often report strange sensations and ghostly sightings near the windmill, making it one of the island’s more mysterious haunted places.
Bonus Haunt: Amityville Horror House - Amityville
No list of haunted places on Long Island would be complete without the infamous Amityville Horror House. After the tragic murders of the DeFeo family in 1974, the Lutz family moved in, only to flee after experiencing terrifying paranormal activity. The house remains one of the most famous haunted locations in the world and continues to draw curious visitors from all over.
Explore the Creepiest Haunted Places on Long Island
From haunted mansions to eerie psychiatric hospitals, Long Island is home to some of the most haunted locations in New York. Whether you're a paranormal enthusiast or just curious about ghost stories, these spooky destinations are sure to send chills down your spine.