Top Bagels on Long Island

Long Island’s Best Bagel Spots, According to Locals

It’s no secret that Long Islanders are passionate about their bagels — and when it comes to finding the best ones, everyone has their go-to spot. We gathered a list of the most beloved bagel joints across the Island, and locals came through with all the classic (and unexpected) favorites. From fresh-out-the-oven classics to creative cream cheese combos, here are the top bagel spots Long Islanders swear by.

🥯 Wally’s Bagels — North Babylon

Why locals love it: Warm, fresh, and consistently delicious — Wally’s is a fan favorite for a reason. Expect lines on weekends, but it’s worth every minute.

Must try: Egg bagel with veggie cream cheese.

🥯 Black Sheep Bagel Co. — Jamesport & Cutchogue

Why locals love it: Artisanal flair, creative sandwiches, and a modern East End vibe. It’s bagels done the farm-to-table way.

Must try: Lox sandwich with house-made everything bagel.

🥯 A&S Bagels — Franklin Square

Why locals love it: A chewy texture and next-level breakfast sandwiches make this spot a staple for early risers and commuters alike.

Must try: Sausage, egg & cheese on a sesame bagel.

🥯 Broadway Gourmet — Massapequa

Why locals love it: Gourmet meets neighborhood favorite. The bagels are fresh, and the menu is stacked with unique options.

Must try: Turkey avocado on a toasted everything.

🥯 Seaford Hot Bagels — Seaford

Why locals love it: A no-frills, always-consistent bagel shop with generous portions and just the right bake.

Must try: Bacon, egg & cheese with hot sauce.

🥯 Town Bagel — Plainview, Bellmore, Wantagh

Why locals love it: With multiple locations and a loyal following, Town Bagel is known for variety, freshness, and fast service.

Must try: Flagel with scallion cream cheese.

🥯 The Better Bagel — Amityville

Why locals love it: A hidden gem with big flavor and inventive spreads. Regulars rave about the cream cheese selection.

Must try: Jalapeño cheddar bagel with maple bacon spread.

🥯 My Three Sons — Stewart Manor, Garden City, Garden City South

Why locals love it: A true family-run operation where every bagel is made with care.

Must try: Egg everything with Nova.

🥯 Goldberg’s — Southampton

Why locals love it: A classic New York-style bagel spot that feels like home.

Must try: Classic plain bagel with whitefish salad.

🥯 Bagel Boss — Island-Wide

Why locals love it: A Long Island bagel empire that’s been delivering the goods for generations. Locations in Bay Shore, Carle Place, East Northport, Hewlett, Hicksville, Jericho, Lake Success, Massapequa, Merrick, Oceanside, Roslyn & Yaphank.

Must try: Egg everything with tofu spread (they have amazing kosher options, too!).

🥯 Hand Rolled Bagels — New Hyde Park

Why locals love it: Simple, soft, chewy bagels done right. No gimmicks — just solid quality.

Must try: Poppy seed with lox spread.

🥯 Max Bialystok Bagels — Long Beach

Why locals love it: Old-school charm and the kind of flavor that keeps locals coming back week after week.

Must try: Pumpernickel with plain cream cheese.

🥯 LI Bagel Café — Multiple Locations

Why locals love it: Bellmore, Glen Cove, Scarsdale, Long Beach, Mineola, Nesconset, Oceanside, Baldwin — no matter where you are, there’s likely a reliable LI Bagel Café nearby.

Must try: French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese.

🥯 Country Hot Bagels — Northport

Why locals love it: Hearty bagels and warm service — perfect for a cozy weekend breakfast.

Must try: Multigrain bagel with egg whites and avocado.

🥯 24 Hour Bagel — Smithtown

Why locals love it: Your late-night savior after a night out or your early-morning fuel. Always hot, always fresh.

Must try: Cinnamon raisin with walnut raisin spread.

🥯 Everything Bagel — Commack & Dix Hills

Why locals love it: Endless variety and bold flavor combos make this place a go-to for adventurous eaters.

Must try: Rainbow bagel with birthday cake cream cheese.

🥯 Beans Bagels — St. James

Why locals love it: A tiny shop with a huge following — and it’s all thanks to their fresh-baked approach.

Must try: Garlic bagel with sun-dried tomato spread.

🥯 Bagel Hut — Farmingdale

Why locals love it: A timeless neighborhood shop that’s stayed true to its roots.

Must try: Salt bagel with lox and onions.

🥯 Pop Up Bagels — Roslyn

Why locals love it: Trendy, elevated, and Instagram-worthy. A foodie’s dream with rotating flavors and top-tier toppings.

Must try: Truffle cream cheese on an everything bagel.

🥯 Bagel Chalet — Merrick, Commack & Plainview

Why locals love it: Consistently chewy, fresh, and flavorful with a loyal fanbase.

Must try: Onion bagel with veggie lite.

🥯 Heavenly Bagels — Levittown

Why locals love it: The name says it all — fluffy, fresh, and divine.

Must try: Cinnamon crunch bagel with honey butter.

🥯 Turnpike Bagels — Levittown

Why locals love it: A true gem tucked into a busy corner, Turnpike delivers every single time.

Must try: Whole wheat everything with bacon scallion cream cheese.

Time to Start Your Bagel Bucket List

Whether you’re a bacon-egg-and-cheese kind of person, an everything bagel purist, or a rainbow bagel adventurer, Long Island has a bagel scene worth exploring. With spots that stretch from the South Shore to the East End, you could easily turn this list into a delicious weekend tour.

Don’t forget to tag @bucketlistli and show us your go-to order, favorite cream cheese flavor, or which shop deserves the crown. We want to see your carb-filled adventures across the island.